14 May Why Nice People Don’t Finish Last: The Science of Kindness, Success, and Real Influence
The phrase “nice guys finish last” has echoed through boardrooms, locker rooms, and dating advice columns for decades. It paints a grim picture: if you’re kind, empathetic, and generous, you’ll be walked all over by ruthless competitors. But here’s the good news; research doesn’t back that up. In fact, when it comes to both career success and life satisfaction, being nice can be a powerful asset.
(NB: if you’d like to have these posts land directly into your inbox, head to the HOME page or the CONTACT US page and sign up to receive my free eNewsletter)
The Myth of the Ruthless Winner
The idea that only aggressive, self-serving individuals rise to the top is largely a myth. It stems from a narrow view of success; one focused solely on wealth, power, and dominance. But long-term success isn’t just about climbing the ladder the fastest; it’s also about how you sustain your position, build relationships, and maintain well-being.
Organisational psychologist Adam Grant, in his book Give and Take, outlines how people fall into three categories: takers, matchers, and givers. Givers those who help others without expecting something in return, are often the most successful in the long run. While some givers get burned out or taken advantage of, many rise to the top because of their ability to build trust, earn loyalty, and foster collaboration.
Science Says: Kindness Pays
A growing body of research supports the idea that kindness and cooperation are linked with long-term success:
- Better teamwork and leadership: A study published in The Journal of Applied Psychology found that leaders who are perceived as warm and empathetic are more effective and respected by their teams. Employees are more likely to go the extra mile for leaders who care.
- Higher performance reviews: Research from the University of Notre Dame showed that employees who are helpful and considerate are more likely to receive strong performance reviews and raises.
- Improved networking and collaboration: Kind people tend to have stronger social networks. When you genuinely care about others, they’re more likely to help you in return, creating a cycle of mutual support and opportunity.
- Greater resilience and lower burnout: Being nice doesn’t mean being a pushover. In fact, studies show that people who practice compassion and gratitude tend to have better emotional resilience, less stress, and higher overall life satisfaction. This allows them to thrive even in demanding environments.
The Long Game of Trust and Reputation
In both life and work, trust is currency. Being consistently kind and ethical builds a strong reputation over time. That reputation can open doors, attract allies, and earn you the benefit of the doubt when things go wrong.
People want to work with those they trust. Clients stay loyal to people they respect. Partners stick with those who treat them well. Even in highly competitive industries, success often hinges on relationships; and relationships flourish when built on mutual respect and kindness.
But What About the Cutthroats?
It’s true that some people succeed through manipulation or aggressive tactics; but that success often comes at a cost. Studies have shown that narcissistic and Machiavellian personalities may rise quickly, but they also fall harder. Their lack of empathy can lead to toxic work environments, high turnover, and eventual isolation.
In contrast, nice people, when they balance kindness with confidence and boundaries, tend to create sustainable success. They build cultures where others thrive, not just survive.
Being Nice Doesn’t Mean Being Weak
Let’s be clear: being nice doesn’t mean being a doormat. Effective kindness is paired with strength, in the form of assertiveness, clarity, and healthy boundaries. It’s knowing when to say no, when to stand up for yourself, and when to protect your energy. It’s about being respectfully firm, not ruthlessly cold.
Final Thoughts
Nice people don’t finish last, they just play a different, longer, and often more rewarding game. They lead with empathy, earn trust, and succeed through collaboration rather than competition. In a world that increasingly values emotional intelligence, kindness isn’t a weakness, it’s a superpower.
So, go ahead. Be nice. It’s not only good for others, it’s good for you, your career, and your happiness.